Paul meets James at Jerusalem
The Passage: Acts 21:18-26
Structure:
a. 21:18, God completed the ministry
b. 21:19-21, Gentiles and the Law
c. 21:22-24, you yourself live in obedience to the Law
b’. 21:25, Gentiles and the Law
a’. 21:26, offering made for each of them
Historical and geographical context:
James. Jesus had two disciples with this name: James, the son of Zebedee, brother of John and James, son of Alphaeus. The first one died from the hand of Herod Agrippa I (Acts 12:1-2). Which leaves James, son of Alphaeus, to be a speaker at the council of Jerusalem (Acts 15:12-21) and a leader of Jerusalem community at the time of Paul’s arrival. Some scholars identify him with James, the brother of Jesus (Mk. 6:3, 15:40). On the other hand, there is a possibility that he is the brother of Matthew/Levi, the tax collector (Mt. 10:3; Mk. 2:14).
Important to note that Jerusalem church re-gained their membership really fast. To understand it we need to compare 8:1-2; 15, and 21:20. St. Luke writes that Jerusalem congregation recovered from a devastating hit on the church by Saul, when only 12 apostles stayed. In chapter 15 we see that the church had both apostles and elders – giving an impression of well-developed leadership, assuming the need for it with a large number of returned or new members. Here James mentions 20,000+ people (21:20). Most of the translations (ESV included) take Greek “murias” as thousands, while in other passages of the Bible rendering it as “tens of thousands” (Acts. 19:19; Rev. 9:16). [it is also interesting to see an avoidance of translation in Rev. 5:11].
Theology:
The Law. In the next stories we need to understand that “the Law” is not simply a set of rules and regulations, it is the Five Books of Moses – Torah, the foundational cornerstone of Jewish way of life, thinking, and acting (Ps. 1:2; Pr. 31:26; Acts 21:28). James said that Jerusalem congregation had at least 20,000 who are zealous for Torah – meaning they belonged to the Pharisees. St. Paul will identify himself as the one in the next story (22:3). He will use the distinction between the Pharisees and Sadducees to his advantage during his defense (23:6-10).
Paul was an observant Jew. The main accusation/suspicion that Jerusalem church had to deal with was teaching the Jews to act like Gentiles. We know he didn’t do that (cp. Eph. 4:17), but to disprove these claims he would participate in the ceremony of the ending of a temporal Nazarene vow by paying the expenses of those who took the vows upon themselves (v. 23-24). Also, it is possible that these guys did not end their vows but – for whatever exact reason – had to start over. The reason for this understanding is based on the reading of Num. 6:6-12. This would explain the reason for “seven days” mentioned at the beginning of the next story (Acts 21:27). The whole company should’ve gone to the Temple to shave their heads and have the arrangements for the next day sacrificial ceremony. If this understanding is correct, then St. Paul did not pay a huge sum of money – 4 pairs of turtledoves or pigeons (Num. 6:10). The payment for the conclusion of the vow is listed in Num. 6:13-15.
At the end of the day – it was not a question about the Gentiles. James simple re-states the same requirements to become a member of the church for the one who did not have Jewish origin, mentioning the Letter of Jerusalem council which he himself proposed (cp. Acts 15:19-21, 23-29; 21:25).
Other themes: Nazarene vows. The full description can be found in the Book of Numbers 6:1-20. Two important notes: vows can be for life (taken by parents) and temporal. We have at least three people who were under the life-long vows: Samson, Samuel, and John the Baptizer. We have examples of people taking a temporal vow (Judg. 5:2 [lit. they let their hair grow loose]; a needed piece of information for a better understanding of 2 Kg. 2:23-25). Then there is a question about Jesus and his possible Nazarene status. He definitely was not a long-life Nazarene (Mt. 11:18-19). Thou, it is possible to read Mt. 26:29 as a part of the vow. This can be a reason why the final drops of vinegar during crucifixion are connected to the completion – therefore, beginning of His kingdom (Mt. 27:48-50; John 19:29). On the other hand, the Nazarene vow does not promote a perpetual sobriety of Jesus – as claimed by SDA and other churches. Num. 6:3 equally prohibit wine and juice, and grapes and raisins.