Feeding of 5000
text: chapter 6
Outline: The chapter has four main blocks:
A. 6:1-15, Feeding of 5000
B. 6:16-21, Jesus walks on water
C. 6:22-59, I am the Bread of Life
D. 6:60-71, Words of Eternal Life
Comments: This is one of the few stories that belongs to all four Gospels – so important! Along with this we have story of Jesus' baptism, trial, crucifixion, and resurrection. To see the feeding of 5000 within this line of events means a lot for its theological importance.
The chapter begins with a story – the story of feeding of 5000. Apart from merciful provision the nutritious aspect of this sign, we have important issues to discuss. First, role of the disciples. We see Philip and Andrew actively participated in the preparation of the miracle. Philip eyeballs the “price-tag” for the feeding of 5000 – 200 dinarii is an amount of money worth of 200 days of regular labor. Probably compatible to $20,000. Andrew, tried to seek an answer of the challenge Jesus placed in front of them (John 6:5). The first disciple – Andrew (cp. John 1:40-42) – is looking for the response to the challenge by the natural means. We understand that it is not going to work... That's why we need a sign from heaven – the Lord's Supper.
Second, the hour of Jesus didn't come yet. That's why the attempt of seizing Him, trying to overthrow the current administration, is pointless. He departs to the mountains (John 6:15). He will come on His own time, and – most importantly – with His own means and for His goals.
Third, His goals should be seen in the context of the sign – it happens during the Passover. The Slain Lamb of annual sacrifices points to the King who comes not to be served, but to serve (cp. Mark 10:45).
Walking on waters. John's version of walking on waters is a connector between the feeding of 5000 and Bread of Life exposition. Among the disciples there were at least four who were professional fishermen – they knew how to handle the stormy waters of the Galilean sea. St. John, being of the fishermen, He is not excited about the event, he simply states that the disciples were glad to take him aboard (John 6:21).
The Bread of Life. This block begins series of statement of Jesus formed as “I am.” Jesus acknowledges the interest of the crowd is based on the satisfaction of their needs (John 6:26), but the needs that lead to the spiritual search – the real work of God is to believe in the Son Who was sent (John 6:29).
Instead of adhering to the words of Jesus, they are asking for the sign, bringing up the wilderness experience of Moses (John 6:31). Jesus reminded them that the true source of bread from heaven was not Moses, but God, Who sent the One who comes down from heaven and gives life to the world (John 6:33).
The chapter was a source of arguments and debates on the Lord's Supper. It is known that Dr. Luther did not supported the interpretation of the chapter in a sacramental matter. This leads to the important distinction between Lutherism and Lutherans. We do respect the teaching of Dr. Martin Luther, but the Church is NOT built on an opinion of one man, but on confession of Christ. The Book of Concord uses John 6 as a sacramental statement (John 6:54 is used in FC, SD VII:61).
Eating and drinking the flesh and blood makes one abide in Jesus (cp. John 15:3-7). This is one of the four “whoever feeds” statements (John 6:54, 56, 57, 58). Then the same idea is developed by Jesus during Last Supper (John 13:18).
The Jews disputing among themselves is strong sign, the same words are used in the Book of Acts 7:26. This time it lead to many of the disciples turning back from Jesus. Next time – in the Book of Acts – the dispute will lead to the death of the first Christian martyr, St. Stephan (Acts 7:57-60).
Words of Eternal Life. The teaching of the Sacramental presence of the Body and the Blood of the Messiah in the Eucharist is not an easy teaching to accept (John 6:60). It is the gift of God, the Father grants the coming to Jesus (John 6:65).
When many disciples left Jesus, He asked the rest: “Do you want to go away as well?” Simon gave Him a response that became an important part of the liturgy, introducing the Gospel reading: Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the Word of Eternal Life” (LSB, p. 173).