Book of Acts: Matthias replaces Judas

Matthias replaces Judas

The Passage: Acts 1:12-26

Structure:

A. 1:12-13, List of the apostles

 B. 1:14-15, the disciples pray

  C. 1:16-17, The OT citation  

   D. 1:18-19, Death of Judas   

  C’. 1:20-22, The OT citation

 B’. 1:23-25, the disciples pray

A’. 1:26, Matthias is added to the list  

Historical and geographical context:

The Eleven (they, cp. Mk. 16:14 and Acts 1:13) came back from Mount Olivet to Jerusalem. The trip was not more than a Sabbath day’s trip – about 1000 [normal] daily steps. Why would they mention that if it was not a sabbath day? They come back to the same place they used to stay during and after the Cross and Resurrection.

They come to the Upper Room – a place where Jesus instituted the His Supper, the higher ground that becomes the source of life for the world. (NB: the Altar in the church – usually – is placed on a higher ground).

The replacement of Judas happened within the 10 days (maybe the first one, but most likely not, 1:15) after the Ascension, prior to Pentecost.    

Theology:

Selection of the ministers – number, timing, personal characteristics.

Number – Peter proposes that the drop-out apostle should be re-placed: “one of these men MUST become with us a witness to his resurrection” (1:22). How many people saw/heard/experienced the resurrection? According to St. Paul – abut 500 (1 Cor. 15:6). This means that the verb “to witness” does not mean the fact of eye witnessing, but the ministry of the Word and Sacrament. The ministry is a witness of His resurrection. For as St. Paul puts is: “if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain” (1 Cor. 15:14). The same applies to the Sacraments – Holy Baptism, Confession and Absolution, and the Sacrament of the Altar.       

Timing – There is an opinion that apostles “jumped the gun”. They should’ve waited for the conversion of Saul. God speaks of him as a “chosen instrument” (Acts 9:15). On the other hand, we do not have any significant acts – sermons, acts of mercy, or miracles – done by Matthias.
That’s where the historical and liturgical heritage helps to answer this question. LSB 517:13 is dedicated to St. Matthias. 

Characteristics. The list of “requirements” is substantially different than what St. Paul would design later for the ministry in diaspora (1 Tim. 3:1-7; Tit. 1:5-6, 7-9). Here: being with us all the time – from the baptism by John to the Ascension. Two criteria: we (1) know him through time (2). Then they prayed for the guidance of the LORD. Prayer and casting lots (cp. Purim, Ex. 28:30; 1 Sam. 14:41-42; Pr. 16:33) was the method of identification.   

Other themes:

Authorship of particular psalms confirmed. It is not an issue here, but later – in Acts 4 we’ll see an important authorship statement. 

120 – the number of disciples (as a whole) was fitting for the following task – sharing the Good News (the Gospel) with the representatives of 15 national and geographical groups.